BabyDiapering & Nursery

10 Best Diaper Pails in 2020

A parent having and using the best diaper pail can be a real lifesaver. These devices keep disposable diapers contained in a unit that’s sealed until it’s ready to be dumped. These pails not only keep the house from smelling like dirty diapers, but they also are convenient to use. A lot more convenient than wrapping each diaper into a plastic bag and throwing it into the trash.

Although these pails are extremely easy to use, it can be sometimes difficult for busy parents to find the one that’s right for their household among all of the available models. That’s why we’ve decided to break down the ten best models available, so parents can choose the one that’s appropriate for them without having to do a ton of research.

My Top 10 Best Diaper Pails Recommendations & Reviews


#10 Bubula Steel Diaper Pail

Check Price on Amazon

This quality diaper pail is made out of a combination of steel and aluminum, and it’s a beautiful grey color that’s stylish in any room. It also features a base that’s a little bit taller than comparable models, so parents don’t have to stoop over as much. Another key feature about this device is that it has a safety lock that keeps pets or children from knocking it over and spilling its contents. Although it’s not as air-tight as we would’ve liked and is a bit expensive, it’s still a great model for parents to use in their nursery.

Pros:

  • Made of metal
  • Has a beautiful look to it
  • Easy to use
  • Feels durable

Cons:

  • Lid isn’t always airtight
  • It’s a bit expensive

#9 Playtex White Diaper Genie

Check Price on Amazon

There’s a reason why Diaper Genie is often considered the gold standard of diaper disposal systems, and that’s because it does a superior job of sealing in diaper odors. It’s because this device is not only made of an antimicrobial plastic that helps to prevent bacteria from congregating within the device, 7-layer refill bags that help to hold in the odor, and a carbon filter to filter out the rest of the odors. Although it doesn’t hold as many diapers as Diaper Genie Deluxe models, it’s still a great pail for just about any parent with a baby still in diapers.

Pros:

  • Has a built-in carbon filter
  • Has a nice look to it
  • Locks air-tight

Cons:

  • Won’t hold as many diapers as Diaper Genie Deluxe models

#8 Munchkin Diaper Disposal Starter Set

Check Price on Amazon

This complete set from Munchkin contains everything a person needs to get started with the proper disposal of their diapers. Not only does it come with a pail, but it also comes with 6 refill bags, a diaper pail refill ring and a baking soda scent puck that smells like lavender. That makes it a great gift for baby showers. Other features found on this model include a self-sealing system that locks in odors and a child-lock to prevent children from spilling the contents. It’s approximately 21.5-inch high and is 12-inches deep. And for every pail that Munchkin sells, they’ll plant a tree to offset the carbon footprint.

Pros:

  • Feels like a very sturdy unit
  • Has a childproof lock to it
  • Comes as a complete set

Cons:

  • More difficult to push diapers into it than it should be

#7 Munchkin Diaper Container With Pedal

Check Price on Amazon

We think this product is better than other Munchkin diaper pails we’ve tried because it’s taller height makes it easier to use. This pail is approximately 27-inches high, and it has an easy-to-use step pedal, so parents don’t have to stoop as much as they would with other diaper disposal systems. Another thing we liked is that it did a good job of sealing out foul diaper odors. Although it’s a bit difficult to squeeze the diapers into this model, it does make for a more airtight system that doesn’t stink too much.

Pros:

  • Has a tall height that makes it easy to use
  • Has a convenient pedal for opening the lid
  • Made out of durable plastic

Cons:

  • Diapers have to be pushed with effort into device

#6 Playtex Diaper Genie Baby Registry Gift Set

Check Price on Amazon

Playtex has done it again with this complete baby gift set. Suitable to give as gifts at baby showers or for placing on baby gift registries, this complete set contains everything a person needs to get started. It comes with the pail made from antimicrobial plastic, 8 Diaper Genie refills and 8 carbon filters. It’s easy to place diapers into this pail, even with full hands, and it does a great job of containing odors. Although removing the bag can be difficult when it’s full, it’s otherwise a great system that will help out any new parent.

Pros:

  • Comes as a complete baby registry gift set
  • Keeps foul diaper odors contained
  • Easy to put diapers into with full hands

Cons:

  • Emptying the bags can be a pain

#5 Dekor Classic Hand-Free Pail

Check Price on Amazon

A lot of diaper pails claim to be hands-free but many of them aren’t. Fortunately for parents, this model just so happens to be hands-free and easy to use as well. It doesn’t require the user to squish the diaper through an impossibly small hole, or unnaturally twist the unit to deposit the diaper into it. That makes it easy to use, although we have to admit it may be a bit small. A good thing about this product is that its made out of closed-cell plastic, so it won’t absorb odors, and it won’t rust either.

Pros:

  • Seals out odor
  • Bags can be changed quickly
  • Easy to use

Cons:

  • Pail is kind of small

#4 Dekor Plus Hands-Free Pail

Check Price on Amazon

The Dekor Plus is a diaper pail that you almost have to love. It’s a hands-free system that eliminates the twisting, bending, and the squishing of diapers through small holes that other pails make the parents endure. And once a diaper has been deposited, it does a great job of keeping the odor from escaping. It also holds a good amount of diapers and is easy to use. All of which would make it a top pick of ours, if it wasn’t for issues with the spring wearing out. With that having been said, it’s still a great pail that’s at least worthy of a look by parents.

Pros:

  • Completely hands-free
  • Holds in diaper older well
  • Doesn’t rust like metal pails

Cons:

  • Spring in it may begin to wear after frequent use

#3 Safety First Easy-Saver Pail

Check Price on Amazon

There are a lot of diaper disposal systems that are pretty complicated, but this one keeps it simple to use. It doesn’t require any special diaper disposal bags, can be used with one hand and is made out of plastic. It does a decent job of holding in diaper smells, and it holds a fair amount of diapers at a time. Although there are some issues with the lid sometimes having to be opened manually because its lid spring isn’t very strong, it’s still a good model for parents with newborns to think about.

Pros:

  • Doesn’t require special diaper disposal bags
  • It’s easy to use
  • Holds in diaper odor well

Cons:

  • Sometimes the lid has to be opened manually

#2 Baby Trend Diaper Champ Deluxe

Check Price on Amazon

In our book, the Baby Trend Diaper Champ is a champ when it comes to containing dirty diapers. This pail has a capacity of approximately 30 diapers, is very easy to use, and provides excellent odor control. It provides better odor control than many of the fancy high-priced models available. Although it would’ve been nice if it had some kind of child-proof lock to keep toddlers out of it, it’s still a good product that works very well and should serve parents with newborns quite well.

Pros:

  • Has excellent odor control
  • It’s easy to use
  • Holds approximately 30 diapers

Cons:

  • Children can easily open it

#1 Ubbi Steel Diaper Pail

Check Price on Amazon

This diaper disposal system from Ubbi has won a ton of awards, and that’s probably because it’s one of the best diaper pails currently available. This model is made out of steel, so it’s not only strong but helps to fully lock in diaper odors. It also has a childproof lock that keeps toddlers from getting into it, and it is easy to use. It also has a large capacity of approximately 50+ diapers. And probably one of the best things about it is that it doesn’t require any special bags to be used.

Pros:

  • It locks in diaper odor
  • It’s easy to use
  • Has a childproof lock
  • Doesn’t require special bags

Cons:

  • None

More products also worth checking out:

A Parent’s Guide To Buying A Diaper Pail

Diaper pails are probably the best invention a parent will ever buy for their home. Not only do they keep soiled diapers or linens safely secured, but they also keep that powerful odor at bay. Unfortunately, too many parents have bad experiences with what they feel are poorly designed diaper pails. And while that may be true in some circumstances, the most likely culprit behind a poorly working diaper pail is the parent.

We realize that parents don’t like to hear it, but sometimes they don’t buy the best diaper pails for their home. They either buy one that’s too small or too large, and this results in them having to empty the pail too often, or not emptying it enough. This can lead to that dreaded smell permeating the entire home. And sometimes, parents just don’t buy the diaper pail that has the features they need.

In this guide, we’re going to remedy the situation and help parents choose a diaper pail that they will love. While we’ve already listed ten of the best diaper pails currently available, this guide will help the parent choose from among those pails to find the best one for their home. Now that we’ve been clear in our purpose, it’s time to find out what parents should be looking for when purchasing a new diaper pail—let’s get started.

Step One: Choose The Right Size Pail

The first thing the parent needs to do is to choose the right diaper pail size. As we stated in our introduction, the size of the pail is probably one of the most important things for parents to consider. Purchase a pail that’s too small, and the parent will be emptying it all day long. Purchase one that’s too big and the diapers will sit in their longer than they should, which creates a horrific smell. Even if the pail effectively seals out odor, the last one is problematic because the parent does eventually have to empty it and that smell can be pervasive.

All of this means that the parents need to take some time and figure out what size pail they need. How do parents decide on a diaper pail size? The first step is to figure out how many diapers are going to be changed per day. On average, most babies go through anywhere from 10 to 20 diapers a day—depending on age. With that information in hand, the parent can then figure out what size pail they need. For most parents, the ideal diaper pail size is one that has a medium size. One that only needs to be emptied every 2-days or so. If the baby goes through 10 diapers a day, then they’ll need a pail that holds approximately 20 to 30 diapers. If the baby goes through 20 diapers a day, then they’ll need a pail that holds approximately 40 to 50 diapers.

Step Two: Consider Liner Cost

The next thing that parents are going to want to consider when purchasing a diaper pail is the cost of its liners. The parent should find out what type of liners the pail uses, and then figure out how much the liners hold to figure out how much it’s going to cost to use liners for a particular diaper pail. Let’s give an example. Let’s say that the parent estimates that their child goes through 300 diapers a month, and one roll of liners can hold up to 600 diapers and has a cost of $20, then the parent is going to be spending approximately $10 a month on pail liners. It’s also important to think about whether the pail can use any appropriately sized diaper pail liner, or if it needs a specific brand of pail liners. If the pail needs a specific brand, then that can add extra cost to the diaper pail budget. That’s because name-brand liners tend to be more expensive.

Step Three: Choose Between Steel Or Plastic Pails

The next thing that the parent is going to want to consider is whether they want a steel or plastic diaper pail. A steel diaper pail is probably going to cost a little bit more than a plastic one, but it’s going to last longer and be easier to maintain. Although we have nothing against plastic pails, the main problem with them is that the plastic can absorb dirty diaper odors. And once the plastic has absorbed those odors, it’s almost impossible to remove it from the plastic.

Step Four: Choose One With An Easy-Open Lid

Although some parent blogs and advice sites suggest that the parent only buys a diaper pail that’s opened with a foot pedal, we think that’s only one of the great mechanisms used today that allow these pails to be used virtually hands-free. For example, some of the Ubbi diaper pails can be opened by pushing the lid cover forward. These pails are easy to open because the parent can use their elbow to push open the hatch and then just drop the diaper down into it. Now don’t get us wrong, we love foot pedals as well, but we do appreciate how the top hatches are less likely to break than foot pedals are.

Step Five: Think About Buying One With A Child-Lock

Although we certainly don’t want to preach to parents to tell them what we think they need, we do feel that buying a diaper pail that’s equipped with a child lock is important. As anyone with a small child can tell you, they get into anything and everything, so if the pail is unlocked or has a lock they can open, then expect about 20 to 30 diapers to end up all over the home.

Step Six: Think About How The Pail Deals With Odors

The last thing that parents are going to want to think about is how the diaper pail deals with odors. At the very least, the pail should be equipped with rubber seals that help to keep those foul diaper odors contained with the pail. Another feature that some pails have is a scented baking soda dispenser that dispenses baking soda in an attempt to mask odors every time the pail is opened. These work alright in controlling odors, but they don’t work nearly as well as the models that use carbon filters. Carbon filters will filter out foul diaper odors, but they do need to be regularly replaced. When buying a pail with carbon filters, consider that they will need to be changed every 30 to 60-days, so be sure to factor that into the diaper pail budget.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Close